By Jenny Kemper•• Updated January 27, 2026• 3 min read
✓
Independent Editorial: Products are chosen independently by our writers. If you buy through our links, LoudFact may earn a commission. Affiliate disclosure • Testing standards
Getting the best eyeliner is what every girl wants. Without eyeliner, our look can easily look incomplete and sloppy. However, with a wide range of brands available in the market, it’s hard to go with eyeliner.
To make things easier for you we reviewed dozens of eyeliners to give you the best of the best. We considered ease of use, duration, smudge-proofing, accuracy of application, cost-effectiveness, user reviews, waterproofing, and size.
Best Eyeliner For Dramatic Look
1. L’Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Pencil Eyeliner
Reviewer says: “This is the best eyeliner! It’s been my favorite for years but has recently proven itself when I went through natural childbirth and lots and lots of crying and was picture-perfect immediately after! Not a smudge!! You can’t go wrong with this stuff!” says one buyer.
2. HAUS LABORATORIES Liquid Eyeliner
Reviewer says: “Love the tip on this. It’s sturdy enough but fine enough to get some really sleek lines. Haven’t worn it for a full day so not sure about how long it’ll last, but so far, love it!” says one buyer.
3. NYX PROFESSIONAL Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner
Reviewer says: “I’m not a makeup type, I wear powder foundation so the quicker the better but this is awesome. So easy to use. The tip is very fine and you can go right to the inner edge of your eyelid with no problem. If I can use this, so can you.” says one buyer.
Reviewer says: “This is the only eyeliner pencil I’ll buy. I’ve tried so many but this goes on easy, stays on, comes off without needing to rub your skin raw, and you don’t need to sharpen it. Plus this black is perfect.” says one buyer.
5. Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner
Reviewer says: “I am 42, very girly and youthful, but in all my life I have never been able to do smudged black eyeliner nicely. Now I know I had the wrong product all along.” says one buyer.
6. iMethod 2 Pens Winged Eyeliner Stamp
Reviewer says: “For the ladies, like myself, who cannot master the perfect cat eye… this is a lifesaver!!! The application is seamless and very easy to use! For me, this product is a game changer!” says one buyer.
7. LA PURE Waterproof Eyeliner Stamp
Reviewer says: “After a little practice with how to exactly place the stamp, this product is so easy to use. I received compliments the first day I wore it in public. It will now be a staple makeup item for myself.” says one buyer.
Disclosure: Bear in mind that some of the links in this post are affiliate links and if you go through them to make a purchase then this blog may receive a commission. Although we receive a commission for using and linking affiliate products, they are extremely good and all our opinion and suggestions are unbiased.
